No Hot Water? Why Your Water Heater Stopped Heating

When a water heater stops heating, the cause depends on the type. On a gas tank heater, it's usually a pilot that went out, a gas supply problem or a failed thermocouple or gas valve. On an electric heater, it's usually a tripped breaker, a burned-out element or a thermostat. Tankless heaters usuall

Nichols technician working on a tankless water heater system in a mechanical room

When a water heater stops heating, the cause depends on the type. On a gas tank heater, it's usually a pilot that went out, a gas supply problem or a failed thermocouple or gas valve. On an electric heater, it's usually a tripped breaker, a burned-out element or a thermostat. Tankless heaters usually show an error code that points to the problem.

First, figure out whether the whole house is cold or just one faucet. Then work through the checks below for your type of heater.

Whole house or one faucet?

Run hot water at a few faucets around the house. If every faucet is cold, the problem is at the water heater. If only one sink or shower is cold, the heater is probably fine and the problem is in that fixture, often a worn mixing valve in a shower or a stuck cartridge in a faucet.

What you noticeLikely cause
No hot water anywhere, gas heaterPilot out, gas off, or a failed thermocouple or gas valve
No hot water anywhere, electric heaterTripped breaker, burned-out element, or a tripped high-limit switch
Tankless unit showing a codeError the unit has detected, often gas, venting or water flow
Hot water runs out fast, then lukewarmFailing element, sediment in the tank, or a heater too small for the house
Only one faucet or shower is coldThe fixture, not the water heater
Water around the base of the tankA leak, which also needs attention

Gas water heater not heating

The pilot light is out

Most standard gas tank heaters have a small pilot flame that lights the burner. Look through the small window near the bottom of the tank. No flame means the pilot is out. A draft, a gas interruption or a failing thermocouple can all put it out.

How relighting a pilot works

Every gas water heater has lighting instructions printed on a label on the tank. Follow those exactly, because they differ by model. Most have you turn the gas control knob to Off and wait for any gas to clear, then turn it to Pilot, hold it down while you light or spark the pilot, keep holding for a short time, and then turn it to On.

The pilot won't stay lit

If the pilot lights but goes out when you let go of the knob, the thermocouple is the usual cause. It's a small sensor that keeps the gas valve open only while the pilot is burning. When it wears out, the valve shuts the gas off. A dirty pilot opening or a draft near the heater can also blow it out.

No gas or propane is getting to it

Check that the gas valve on the line to the heater is open, with the handle running in line with the pipe. If your home runs on propane, check the tank gauge. When the propane runs out, everything that uses it stops, and the system needs a leak check before gas goes back on.

The gas valve has failed

The gas control valve on the front of the tank opens the gas and controls the temperature. If the pilot lights and stays lit but the burner never comes on, the valve may have failed. That's a repair for a plumber.

Nichols technician working on a tankless water heater system in a mechanical room
Gas, electric and tankless heaters each fail in their own ways.

Electric water heater not heating

Electric tank heaters have no flame. They heat with one or two elements inside the tank, each controlled by its own thermostat.

  • Tripped breaker. Check the water heater's double breaker in the panel. Reset it once. If it trips again, leave it off and call
  • High-limit switch. Many electric heaters have a red reset button behind the upper access panel. It trips when the water gets too hot. If it keeps tripping, a thermostat may be stuck
  • Burned-out element. A failed upper element usually means no hot water at all. A failed lower element usually means hot water that runs out fast
  • Thermostat. A thermostat that fails can keep an element from ever turning on

Tankless water heater not heating

A tankless heater only fires when water is flowing. When it doesn't heat, check the display first. Most show an error code, and the owner's manual explains what each one means. Common causes include no gas or propane, a venting problem, too little water flow to trigger the burner, or mineral scale built up inside the heat exchanger.

Hard water is a big factor here. Scale builds up faster in tankless units, which is why they need flushing. Our post on hard water in the Verde Valley explains why it's such a common problem in this area.

Technician servicing a wall-mounted tankless water heater
Tankless units show an error code that points to the problem.

Lukewarm instead of hot

Lukewarm water is a different problem from no hot water. On a tank heater, sediment on the bottom of the tank, a failing element or a thermostat set too low are the usual causes. The U.S. Department of Energy says 120°F is enough for most homes, so check the setting before assuming something broke. If hot water has always run out quickly since you moved in, the heater may simply be too small for your household.

What we hear on calls

No-hot-water calls come from homes, rentals and businesses. A school told us its water heater wouldn't heat: "Maybe the pilot light is out." Another caller wasn't sure where the problem was: "I don't know if it's my hot water heater." Some people just need help with the pilot: "I need someone to come and light the pilot please."

Short-term rental owners call when a guest has no hot water, and one Village of Oak Creek owner called because "our guest bathroom is not getting hot water." Tankless owners call too, like one whose propane "tank ran dry and everything else restarted, but this cannot," and another whose heater was "giving me a system code error."

When to call a plumber

Call when the pilot won't light or won't stay lit, the breaker keeps tripping, a tankless code keeps coming back, you smell gas, or there's water around the tank. Our water heater service covers repairs and replacements for standard and tankless heaters. You get the price after we diagnose it and before any work starts.

If the tank itself is leaking, it can't be repaired. Our guide to water heater leaks explains where leaks start, and our post on water heater replacement cost covers what drives the price of a new one. Current offers are on our coupons page.

We serve Sedona from our Cottonwood shop. See plumbing in Sedona.

Questions

On a gas heater, the pilot may be out or the gas may be off. On an electric heater, the breaker may have tripped or an element may have failed. A tankless heater usually shows an error code. If only one faucet is cold, the problem is that fixture, not the heater.

Still no hot water?

Call the Nichols crew. We'll find what failed and give you the price before any work starts.

Licensed, bonded and insured · 24/7 emergency service

David Nichols

David Nichols founded Nichols Plumbing, Electrical, & HVAC in Cottonwood in 2017 with Desirea Nichols. The family-owned, triple-licensed team handles plumbing, heating, cooling and electrical work across the Verde Valley, Sedona and the Prescott area.

Request service

In a pickle? Request service today.

Tell us what's going on and we'll get you on the schedule. For emergencies, call and we'll dispatch right away.

  • We answer 24/7
  • Transparent pricing
  • Licensed, bonded & insured
Nichols technician arriving at a customer's front door
(928) 300-1221 Request Service