If your furnace is about 20 years old, start planning to replace it, even if it still runs. ENERGY STAR suggests considering replacement once a furnace is more than 15 years old. A small, cheap repair can still make sense to get you through the winter. A big repair on a furnace that age usually doesn't.
Here's how to decide when to replace a furnace: what broke, how often it breaks, whether parts are still made, and what the colder Prescott-area winters ask of it.
How long a gas furnace lasts
There's no fixed expiration date. How long a furnace lasts depends on how well it was sized and installed, how often the filter got changed, and whether it was serviced. What we do know: ENERGY STAR says to consider replacing a furnace or boiler once it's more than 15 years old. At 20 years, yours is past that mark.
Age alone doesn't mean a furnace is unsafe. But older furnaces wear in ways that cost more to fix, parts get harder to find, and they burn more gas for the same heat than newer models. ENERGY STAR says a certified furnace is 15% more efficient than a conventional one.
Repair or replace: what broke matters
The part that failed tells you a lot. Here's how we think about common repairs on a furnace that's around 20 years old:
| What failed | On a 20-year-old furnace | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Igniter, flame sensor or capacitor | Usually repair | Small, common parts. A fix gets you through the season while you plan |
| Thermostat or wiring | Repair | Not the furnace itself |
| Inducer or blower motor | Depends | A bigger repair. Weigh it against the furnace's age and how often it breaks |
| Control board | Often replace | Boards for older models can be hard to find, and the cost adds up |
| Gas valve | Depends | Fine to fix on a furnace in good shape. Less so if other parts are wearing out too |
| Cracked heat exchanger | Usually replace | A crack can let exhaust into your air. On an older furnace, replacement is usually the better spend |
| Parts no longer available | Replace | When the part isn't made anymore, there's nothing to repair with |
Many techs use a simple test: if a repair costs half or more of what a new furnace would, and the furnace is near the end of its life, put the money toward a new one.
Signs it's time to replace your furnace
- It needs repairs every season. One fix a year adds up fast on an old unit
- Your gas bill keeps climbing and you haven't changed how you heat
- Some rooms never get warm while others get too hot
- The flame looks yellow or lazy instead of steady blue, or there's soot around the burners
- Your carbon monoxide alarm has gone off. Get out first, then call
- A tech found a cracked heat exchanger
- Parts for your model are no longer made
- Your AC is also old and you'd like the two to be replaced as a matched system
Prescott-area homes see colder winters than the Verde Valley, so a furnace up here works harder and longer each year. That makes the age question come up sooner.
What we hear on calls
Sometimes the decision gets made for you. One homeowner whose repair stalled put it plainly: "I guess it came down to not being able to get the parts to repair my old furnace."
Landlords call too, like one whose rental furnace went out and who was "trying to figure out approximately what it might cost to replace it." And buyers worried about an original furnace call during home sales.
If you replace it
A new gas furnace isn't your only choice. Some homes switch to a heat pump, and some pair a heat pump with a gas furnace as backup. Our post on heat pump vs. gas furnace in Prescott walks through how each one handles cold nights at this elevation.
Our heating installation team installs new furnaces and heat pumps. You get the price before any work starts. Already have a quote from another company? We'll give you a free second opinion. Current offers are on our coupons page.
We serve Prescott and Prescott Valley from our Prescott Valley shop. See our services in Prescott.
Before you decide
- Find the furnace's age from the data plate
- Get a written diagnosis of what failed and what it costs to fix
- Ask whether the part is still made and how soon it can arrive
- Add up what you've spent on repairs in the last two winters
- Check the age of your AC, since replacing both together can make sense
- Ask about a heat pump or a dual-fuel setup if you're curious
- If a crack or carbon monoxide came up, don't run the furnace while you decide
If you decide to keep it a few more years, a yearly heating tune-up is the best way to catch problems early. Our post on furnace care habits covers what you can do between visits.
Questions
Old furnace acting up?
Call the Nichols crew. We'll find the cause and give you the price before any work starts.
Licensed, bonded and insured · Free second opinion




